
We are delighted to introduce this timely and thought-provoking blog, ‘Transformative Leaders Begin by Looking Within’.
In this piece, Deirdra Preis explores why critically reflexive practice matters for school leaders who are committed to equity and social justice. Distinguishing reflexivity from routine reflection, the author considers how leaders can examine the assumptions, experiences of power and implicit biases that shape their decisions. The author makes the case for embedding reflexive practice in leadership preparation, coaching and professional learning, so that leaders are better equipped to sustain liberatory practice through challenging and contested times.
If you have any comments or thoughts about this blog and the points it raises, then do share on social media using the hashtag #BELMASblog or contact the BELMAS Blog editorial team by emailing: blog@belmas.org.uk
Today’s school leaders serve increasing numbers of students with diverse, complex learning profiles (Banks, 2024). Often stuck in the middle of highly polarized debates around equity, they can face significant resistance when challenging the status quo to close opportunity gaps. Through conversations that took place in two leadership research studies, professional learning programs for midlevel practitioners, and over seven years preparing prospective school leaders, I’ve found that many have not received training, either from their preparation programs or professional learning opportunities, to help them stay focused and committed to liberatory practices through turbulent times.
What Sets Transformative School Leaders Apart from Others
What dispositions and skills do leaders need to maintain equity and excellence at the core of their work, even when faced with controversy? Most would agree that compassion, a strong social justice orientation, collaborative skills, and proficiency in instructional coaching are essential. But good intentions and technical skill alone don’t automatically keep leaders focused and willing to “go the distance”.
But one characteristic that sets these leaders apart is a commitment to something that is often left out of leadership curricula and professional trainings: critically reflexive practice.
Reflexive Versus Reflective Practice
What does it mean to be a critically reflexive practitioner?
Most leaders are accustomed to reflecting on their decisions. However, simple reflection, when limited to exploring facts and logic, is unlikely to raise attention to or disrupt oppressive patterns of thinking or doing that may reduce their impact – or point out when they are succumbing to pressure to stray from what is best for students. Critical reflexivity, on the other hand, demands a deeper dive. All educators have implicit biases and cultural limitations which, if left unchecked, can reduce their capacity to improve opportunity for underserved students (Khalifa, et al. 2016). Transformative leaders know this and acknowledge the risks and pressures that can cause them to deviate from their commitments. Thus, they are compelled to hold themselves accountable for ensuring their decisions truly align with their professed commitments to liberatory practice, regularly posing such questions as:
These questions push beyond logic, helping leaders uncover unconscious behaviors that interfere with “seeing” and serving every student such as color evasiveness, meritocratic thinking, or a tendency to “save” rather than empower others. When undertaken with humility and honesty, reflexive practice can bring out how their positionalities, including their experiences of power, shape their priorities and perspectives – and ultimately influence their potential to disrupt systemic injustices (Radd et al., 2021). This self-knowledge can help maintain the integrity and clarity of their work and sustain their commitment to the complex responsibilities of transformative leadership.
Critical Reflexivity Can Be Learned
The good news is that reflexive thinking isn’t a personality trait. It’s a discipline that can be developed through practice – and should be an ongoing expectation of every aspiring and practicing school leader.
A logical starting place is in leadership preparation. Rather than limiting the teaching of equity to conceptual discussions or data-informed decision making, faculty can create additional opportunities that help aspiring leaders connect their lived experiences to their decision-making using reflexive journals, cultural autobiographies, community immersion, and peer dialogue to help develop clarity and resolve around their social justice platforms (Radd et al., 20). They can also model protocols that require gathering multiple perspectives and incorporate reflexive questioning in the problem-solving process (Gorski & Pothini, 2017). Where formal leadership preparation doesn’t exist, reflexivity can be integrated into induction programs, professional fellowships, coaching, and mentoring (Radd et al., 2021).
Reflexive Practice Should be a Professional Expectation
Given its significance to transformative practice, why isn’t reflexive work more present in school leader preparation and development? For one, it’s a rigorous process which demands more of faculty, coaches, and mentors to make space for honest, sometimes controversial dialogue around bias and power (DeCosta & Gooden, 2025). Furthermore, self-discovery isn’t always easy or comfortable, and it can’t be found in a textbook or using AI.
However, education has long been viewed as one of society’s most powerful vehicles for expanding opportunity. If that’s still our belief, then fulfilling its promise requires an expectation of – and support for – critically reflexive practice in school leaders. By not prioritizing it, we risk creating managers of the status quo rather than leaders who can act bravely and intentionally to advocate for the students who need them most. Because the fact is that transforming schools doesn’t begin with designing strategic plans. It begins with developing leaders who have the courage and humility to work on themselves – approaching their work from the inside out.
Banks, J. A. (2024). Introduction: the global quest for educational equity. Daedalus, 153(4), 6-20.
DeCosta, D. B., & Gooden, M. A. (2024). The Change You Want to See: A Culturally Responsive and Affirming Approach to School Leadership. Solution Tree Press.
Gorski, P. & Pothini, S. (2017, December 19). Equity Case Analysis Process. EdChange and the Equity Literacy Institute.
Khalifa, M. A., Gooden, M. A., & Davis, J. E. (2016). Culturally responsive school leadership: A synthesis of the literature. Review of Educational Research, 86(4), 1272-1311.
Radd, S. I., Generett, G. G., Gooden, M. A., & Theoharis, G. (2021). Five practices for equity-focused school leadership. ASCD.